Categories
Home Buying TipsPublished November 18, 2026
Is a Home Warranty Worth It When You Buy a House?
Quick answer: For most buyers, a home warranty isn't worth paying for yourself. In our experience, only about 2% of buyers end up with one. A plan typically costs about $56 to $73 a month in 2026, plus a service fee of roughly $75 to $125 every time a technician comes out, and coverage usually lasts a year. Warranties also exclude problems they consider pre-existing and some parts of covered systems. When inspection turns up repairs, we usually ask for a seller credit first, because it gives you the most flexibility. A warranty makes the most sense when the home's systems are older, when you'd struggle to cover a big repair in your first year, or when the seller offers one in place of a repair or credit.
Is a home warranty worth the money, or is it just one more thing to pay for at closing? And if something breaks the month after you move in, what will you actually pay out of pocket?
By the end of this article, you'll know what a home warranty really covers, what it costs, and how to decide whether one makes sense for the home you're buying. We'll walk through typical plan prices, the fine print behind most denied claims, when we've seen a warranty help, and how it compares with asking the seller for a repair or a credit.
What does a home warranty cover?
A home warranty is a service contract that pays for repairs to certain home systems and appliances when they break down from normal use. Coverage depends entirely on the plan you buy. Some plans fix certain parts, and others will replace the item. Some cover only the major systems, and some cover systems plus appliances. What you're covered for comes down to what you pay up front. Most plans buyers get at closing last one year.
A warranty is not homeowners insurance, and buyers often mix the two up.
| Home warranty | Homeowners insurance | |
|---|---|---|
| What it covers | Repair or replacement of covered systems and appliances that break down from normal wear | Damage to your home and belongings from events like fire or storms, plus liability |
| Required? | No, completely optional | Required by mortgage lenders |
| What you pay per claim | A service call fee per visit | A deductible |
| Common exclusions | Pre-existing conditions, lack of maintenance, coverage caps | Wear and tear, neglect, certain natural disasters |
Sources: Bankrate, "Home warranty vs. homeowners insurance" (2025); Opendoor, "Are Home Warranties Worth It?" (2026).
How much does a home warranty cost?
A home warranty costs $73 a month on average in 2026, or about $876 a year, according to NerdWallet's analysis, with plans ranging from $28 to $191 a month. Service fees averaged $108.45 per service call. This Old House's 2026 cost study, based on more than 4,000 quotes, put the average lower, at $56 a month, with service call fees of $75 to $125 per visit. Price depends on your location, the plan level, add-ons, and the service fee you choose.
Here's what a first year could look like using NerdWallet's averages. This is an illustration, not a specific plan or client.
| Cost | Amount |
|---|---|
| Annual plan (at $73 a month) | $876 |
| Two service calls (at $108.45 each) | $217 |
| First-year total | About $1,093 |
If nothing covered breaks that year, you've spent the plan cost and gotten nothing back. If the seller gave you a credit for the same amount instead, you'd keep it.
What do buyers miss in a home warranty's fine print?
The fine print is where most buyers get surprised, and they usually don't find out until they file a claim. Three things come up the most.
Parts of a system may not be covered
You might have a warranty on your heater, but a specific pilot light issue might not be covered, and that might be the actual problem. Covering a system doesn't always mean covering every piece of it.
Early problems can be treated as pre-existing
If something breaks too soon after coverage starts, the warranty company may consider it a pre-existing condition. Many plans also have a waiting period at the start, often around the first month, before claims are accepted. Read your policy's timelines so you know when a claim will count.
You don't choose who does the work
If you'd rather have a friend or family member fix it, or hire a licensed contractor you trust to make sure it doesn't happen again, a warranty often won't allow that. The company sends its own technician.
National survey data points the same way. In This Old House's 2026 home warranty survey of 2,000 homeowners, the most common reasons for a denied claim were pre-existing conditions (29%), the item not being covered (29%), the cost going over the plan's cap (20%), and lack of maintenance (13%).
When is a home warranty not worth it?
If you're buying a newer home with newer systems and thinking about paying for a warranty yourself, we'd say definitely not. Even when a seller offers to pay for one, we'd usually rather have something else, unless there's no way the seller will agree to a credit or a price reduction. In that case, why not take it? The seller is paying.
Many buyers we work with ask for seller assist instead, which is a credit toward their closing costs. Because it lowers what you pay at closing, more of your own savings stays in the bank, where it's there for any repair down the road. A warranty, by comparison, usually lasts a year.
When does a home warranty make sense?
A warranty makes more sense when the systems in the house are older, and when you're worried about that first year and don't have money set aside to repair something. If you'll have money left over after closing, you may prefer to ask for a credit or a seller repair instead.
Timing matters too. On one recent deal, we discovered a problem with the water heater right before closing. Changing the seller assist that late in the process might have caused issues with the loan, so a credit wasn't a good option. The water heater issue still had to be fixed before closing, and the seller also paid for a home warranty, so if the water heater broke down again after the buyers moved in, the warranty would cover it. The buyers were protected going forward without putting the closing at risk.
Should you ask the seller for a warranty, a repair, or a credit?
If the home inspection turns up repairs, buyers usually ask the seller for one of two things: a credit toward closing costs or a repair before closing. We usually start by asking for a credit, because it's the most flexible. You can use the savings however you need, and if you know people who can do the work, you control how it's done. A repair is the better fit if you don't want to deal with the issue after closing or don't have contractors you trust. Having the seller fix it so you can move in and not worry about it is sometimes the best course of action.
A home warranty usually comes up only when the seller won't agree to either, or when it's too late in the process for one. In our deals, it's typically the seller who offers it as a last resort, and if you still want the home, it's worth considering.
| Seller credit (seller assist) | Seller repair | Home warranty | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you get | Money toward your costs at closing | The issue fixed before you move in | Coverage for certain breakdowns, usually for one year |
| Your control | High: you choose who does the work and when | Low: the seller arranges the work | Low: the warranty company sends its technician |
| Best when | You have contractors you trust and want flexibility | You don't want to manage repairs after closing | Systems are older, cash is tight, or it's too late for a credit or repair |
| Watch out for | Late changes can cause problems with your loan | Quality of work you didn't choose | Exclusions, caps, service fees, and a one-year term |
Some repairs aren't up to you. If your lender requires something to be fixed, for example because it came up in the appraisal, it has to be repaired. Everything outside that is what we make a plan for together.
How does getting a home warranty work from offer to move-in?
If a home warranty ends up in your deal, it's usually because of what the home inspection found. Those negotiations happen during the inspection period, usually the first 10 days or so of being under contract, depending on what your agreement allows. Buyers are usually at the inspection, so they see the issues firsthand, and when the report comes in, we look at the dollar amounts together and decide whether to ask for a credit or a repair. Some inspection companies include repair estimates in the report, which makes that conversation easier. If the seller won't agree to either, they'll sometimes offer a home warranty instead, which gets added to the contract as a change in terms.
If you negotiate a warranty and the seller is paying, make sure it's set up before closing. Then, once you move in, read your policy and learn its timelines, including any waiting period, so that if you need to file a claim, you're filing within the right window.
Decide on a home warranty before you need one
You probably came here wondering whether a home warranty is worth the cost, and what you'd really be covered for if something broke right after you moved in.
Now you know that a seller credit often gives buyers more flexibility than a warranty, that a warranty's value depends on the age of the home and how much cushion you'll have after closing, and that exclusions, caps, and waiting periods decide what a plan is actually worth.
Your next step is to understand the inspection period, because that's when the warranty, repair or credit decision gets made. Read our guide to what happens during a home inspection so you know what to look for and when to ask. And if you're getting ready to buy and want help thinking through these options for your situation, talk to our team.
Frequently asked questions
Who pays for a home warranty when you buy a house?
Usually the seller. In our deals, a warranty most often comes up after the inspection, when the seller offers one in place of a repair or credit. Buyers can also buy a plan on their own.
Does a home warranty cover problems found during the inspection?
Usually not. Warranties commonly exclude pre-existing conditions, so an issue already known at inspection is better handled with a repair or a credit.
How long does a home warranty last?
The plans buyers get at closing typically last one year. Some can be renewed after that at your own cost.
Is a home warranty the same as homeowners insurance?
No. Insurance covers damage from events like fire or storms and is required by your lender. A warranty covers breakdowns of systems and appliances and is optional.
Robin Martin
Realtor® | Premier Home Team | Keller Williams Empower | PLACE
or another way
